Sabtu, 03 Desember 2011

Access to Knowledge: Implications of Universal Design for CALL Environments

%3Ch3+class%3D%22post-title+entry-title%22%3E%0D%0A+Access+to+Knowledge%3A+Implications+of+Universal+Design+for+CALL+Environments+%3C%2Fh3%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22post-header%22%3E%0D%0A++%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22journal%22%3E%0D%0A+++%3Cul%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EISSN+1442-438X%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3ECALL-EJ+Online%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EVol.+5%2C+No.+2%2C+January+2004%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Ful%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22title%22%3E%0D%0A++%3Ch2%3E%0D%0A%0D%0A%3C%2Fh2%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22author%22%3E%0D%0A+++%3Cul%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EJoy+Lynn+Egbert%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3E%3Ca+href%3D%22mailto%3Aegbert%40mail.wsu.edu%22%3Eegbert%40mail.wsu.edu%3C%2Fa%3E%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EWashington+State+University%2C+U.S.A.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Ful%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22article%22%3E%0D%0A+++++%3Cdiv+class%3D%22chapter%22%3E%0D%0A++++%3Ch3%3E%0D%0AAbstract%3C%2Fh3%3E%0D%0AThe++purpose+of+this+conceptual+paper+is+to+explore+Universal+Design%2C+a+++model+from+the+field+of+architecture+and+design+that+is+finding+recent+++applications+in+education.+Called+Universal+Instructional+Design+%28UID%29+++when+applied+in+education%2C+UID+environment+conditions+are+similar+in+++many+ways+to+conditions+that+effective+language+teachers+design+into+++their+instructional+environments.++This+paper+addresses+how+the+UID+++model+might+profitably+be+applied+in+computer-assisted+language+learning+++%28CALL%29+classrooms+to+help+all+of+our+students+gain+access+to+classroom+++instruction++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22chapter%22%3E%0D%0A++++%3Ch3%3E%0D%0AIntroduction%3C%2Fh3%3E%0D%0AIn+the+past+it+has++often+been+profitable+to+explore+the+ways+in+which++theories%2C++principles%2C+and+models+from+other+disciplines+apply+to+what+we+know+++about+and+do+in+language+classrooms+%28for+a+very+interesting+example%2C+see+++Larsen-Freeman%27s+1997+application+of+Chaos+Theory+to+second+language++acquisition%29.+By++having+taken+such+an+approach%2C+we+have+not+only++learned+more+about+related++fields%2C+but+we+have+also+opened+the+field+of++language+learning+to+entertaining+possibilities+that+might+not++otherwise+be+considered.+In+many+cases%2C++these+cross-disciplinary++explorations+have+provided+additional+support+for++existing+theories++about+how+language+classrooms+should+operate%3B+in+others%2C+they+have+added++a+new+dimension+to+our+investigations+of+language+learning.+This+type++of+examination+remains+valuable+as+we+develop+new+theories+and+models+of++language+learning.++++%0D%0AThe+purpose+of+this+paper+is+to+explore+Universal+Design%2C+a+model+from+++the+field+of+architecture+and+design+that+is+finding+recent+applications+++in+education.+This+paper+first+introduces+the+Universal+Design+model+++and+then+describes+recent+discussions+of+the+model+in+education.+The+++paper+next+suggests+how+the+model+relates+to+CALL+environment+conditions+++and+provides+examples+and+discussion+of+how+this+model+might+be+++implemented+in+CALL+classroom+environments.++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22chapter%22%3E%0D%0A++++%3Ch3%3E%0D%0AUniversal+Design%3C%2Fh3%3E%0D%0AUniversal+Design++%28UD%29+is+widely+defined+as+%22the+design+of+products+and+environments+to++be+usable+by+all+people%2C+to+the+greatest+extent++possible%2C+without+the++need+for+adaptation+or+specialized+design%22+%28Bowe%2C+2001%2C+p.24%29.+Products++and+environments+designed+with+UD+principles+in+mind++++%0D%0A%3Cul%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3Eare+designed+to+be+used+by+as+many+people+as+possible.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3Ecan+be+used+in+ways+that+people+choose.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3Eare+easy+to+understand+and+use.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3Ework%2Fare+accessible+in+all+kinds+of+settings.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3Eaccommodate+error.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3Erequire+minimal+physical+effort+to+use+and+accommodate++differences+in+size+or+position.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Ful%3E%0D%0A%28adapted+from+Bowe+2000%3B+Burgstahler%2C+2002%3B+Connell%2C+Jones%2C+Mace%2C+++Mueller%2C+Mullick%2C+Ostroff%2C+Sanford%2C+Steinfeld%2C+Story%2C+%26amp%3B++Vanderheiden%2C+1997%29++++%0D%0AExamples+of+products+and+enDironments+designed+on+the+basis+of+these+++conditions+include+power+doors+on+buildings%2C+child-proof+but+older-adult++accessible+bottle+tops%2C+products+that+include+instructions+for+assembly++in+multiple+formats+%28e.g.%2C+text%2C+graphic%2C+and+video%29%2C+and+homes+and++offices+that+are+compliant+with+the+U.S.+Americans+with+Disabilities+Act++%28ADA%29.+Although+these+principles+may+seem+simple+and+possibly++intuitive%2C+it+is+easy+to+call+to+mind+examples+of+products+and++environments+that+were+not++designed+based+on+UD+principles.+Many++language+classroom+environments%2C+based++implicitly+on+a+%22one+size+fits++all%22+model%2C+fall+into+this+category.+However%2C+educators+of+all+kinds+are++adapting+UD+principles+to+make+education+more+accessible%2C+as+outlined++below.++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22chapter%22%3E%0D%0A++++%3Ch3%3E%0D%0AUniversal+design+in+instruction%3C%2Fh3%3E%0D%0AHatfield++and+Fox+%282001%29+point+out+that+the+inclusion+and+multicultural+++education+movements+in+the+U.S.%2C+along+with+new+discoveries+about+++learning+styles+and+other+learner+differences%2C+have+facilitated+the+++relatively+recent+move+of+UD+into+education%2C+where+it+is+commonly+called+++Universal+Instructional+Design+%28UID%29.+In+part%2C+the+impetus+for+the+++migration+of+UD+principles+to+education+is+the+realization+that+access+++to+education+for+all+students+does+not+mean+merely+physical+access+++%28e.g.%2C+by+means+of+wheelchair+ramps+and+note+takers%29%2C+but+access+to+++information%2C+resouNces%2C+tools%2C+and+opportunities.+Burgstahler+%282002%29+++notes+that++++%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22paragraph%22%3E%0D%0A++++++Universal+Design+principles+can+apply+to++lectures%2C+classroom++discussions%2C+group+work%2C+handouts%2C+Web-based++instruction%2C+labs%2C++fieldwork%2C+and+other+academic+activities+and++materials.+They+give+each++student+meaningful+access+to+the+curriculum++by+assuring+access+to+the++environment+as+well+as+multiple+means+of++representation%2C+expression%2C+and++engagement+%28p.1%29.+++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0AStrehorn+%282001%29+and+other+educators+interested+in+the+educational+++applications+of+UID+tap+the+broad+research+base+underlying+the+model+to+++propose+that+these+principles+can+be+used+to+transform+not+only+the+++physical+environment+of+the+classroom+but+also+instruction%2C+curricular+++content%2C+and+materials.+According+to+UID%2C+rather+than+providing+access+++on+a+case-by-case+basis%2C+all+of+these+instructional+components+should+be+++designed+a+priori+to+be+accessible+by+the+greatest+number+of+learners+++possible.+In+other+words%2C+UID+does+not+imply+that+one+universal+size+++fits+all+but+more+that+a+diversity+of+opportunities+will+work+for+many+++different+students.++Burgstahler+%282002%29+notes+that+beneficiaries+of+UID+++can+include+students+with+varying+cultures%2C+abilities%2C+backgrounds%2C+and+++learning+needs.+These+students+benefit+because++++%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22paragraph%22%3E%0D%0A++++++In+terms+of+learning%2C+universal+design++means+the+design+of+instructional+materials+and+activities+that+makes++the+learning+goals+achievable+by++individuals+with+wide+differences+in++their+abilities+to+see%2C+hear%2C+speak%2C+move%2C++read%2C+write%2C+understand++English%2C+attend%2C+organize%2C+engage%2C+and+remember.++Universal+design+for++learning+is+achieved+by+means+of+flexible+curricular++materials+and++activities+that+provide+alternatives+for+students+with+differing+++abilities.+These+alternatives+are+built+into+the+instructional+design++and+operating+systems+of+educational+materials-they+are+not+added+on++after-the-fact.+%28Council+for+Exceptional+Children%2C+1999%2C+p.+2%29+++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0AEducators+can+build+in+principles+of+UID+by+preparing+to+%22present++information+in+multiple+ways---offer+multiple+ways+for+students+to+++interact+with+and+respond+to+curricula+and+materials+%28give+them+choices++of+pace%2C+how+to+respond%2C+how+to+get+the+information%29q%C2%A5%C2%BCand%5D+provide++multiple+ways+for+students+to+find+meaning+in+the+material+and+thus++motivate++themselves%22+%28Bowe%2C+2000%2C+p.4%29.+Izzo+%282002%29+concludes+that++applying+Universal+Design+in+education+%22is+just+good+teaching%22+%28np%29.++++%0D%0ABurgstahler+%282002%29+and+other+authors+have+suggested+that+meeting+UID+++conditions+might+provide+ESL+students+with+more+access+to+curricula.++Strehorn++%282001%29+presents+specific+applications+of+UID+principles+to++conditions+in+higher+education+ESL+classrooms%2C+noting%2C+%22ESL+and+UID+are+a++natural+fit%22+%28p.1%29%2C+and+this+is+particularly+true+in+language+learning++environments+enhanced+by+computer+technologies.+In+fact%2C+a+comparison+of++UID+and++effective+CALL+environments+shows+that+they+overlap+in+many++ways.++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22chapter%22%3E%0D%0A++++%3Ch3%3E%0D%0AUID+and+CALL+Environment+Conditions%3C%2Fh3%3E%0D%0AIn++this+section%2C+each+of+the+six+components+of+UD+environments+presented++previously+is+followed+by+a+more+detailed+description+of+its+++instructional+application+and+a+brief+summary+of+its+role+in+CALL++environments.+The++discussion+of+second+language+acquisition+%28SLA%29++theory+and+research+is+adapted+from+Egbert%2C+Hanson-Smith%2C+%26amp%3B+Chao++%281999%29%2C+who+have+drawn+on+diverse++theories+and+research+studies+to++develop+a+set+of+conditions+for+optimal+CALL++environments.+These++conditions+and+the+foundations+upon+which+they+are+built+provide+one+way++of+visualizing+the+design+of+effective+CALL+environments+and++they++allow+parallels+between+the+two+types+of+environments+to+be+drawn+++easily.++++%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22paragraph%22%3E%0D%0A+++++%3Ch4%3E%0D%0A1.+Equitable+use%3C%2Fh4%3E%0D%0A%0D%0A%3Cul%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EUseful+to+and+accessible+by+diverse+learners%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EAppealing%2Fmotivating+to+all+learners%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EIdentical+OR+equivalent+instruction%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Ful%3E%0D%0A%0D%0AEquitable+use+is+also+important+to+CALL+classrooms.+For+example%2C+SLA+++theory+proposes+that+authentic+tasks+are+motivating+for+language++learners%3B+such+tasks+are+by+definition+useful+to+and+accessible+by++diverse+learners.++Both+UID+and+the+TESOL+standards+%28TESOL%2C+1997%29++require+that+classrooms+will+be+welcoming+to+all+learners+and+that++materials+and+instruction+will+be+appropriate+for+learners%27+levels+and++needs.+This+implies%2C+for+example%2C+that+text+sets%2C+or+texts+with+the+same++information+at+different+reading+levels%2C+will+be+used+if+needed.+In++CALL+classrooms%2C+such+sets+of++readings+can+be+found+by+searching+the++World+Wide+Web.+The+Internet+can+also+be+a+source+of+appealing+and++motivating+instruction+that+learners+find+to+be+useful%2C+for+example%2C++making+connections+with+native+speakers+or++discovering+information+that++is+useful+to+their+lives+outside+of+class.+++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22paragraph%22%3E%0D%0A+++++%3Ch4%3E%0D%0A2.+User+control%3C%2Fh4%3E%0D%0A%0D%0A%3Cul%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EVarious+methods+of+engagement%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EVarious+tools%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EChoices+in+control+and+pace%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EChoices+of+participation+structures%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Ful%3E%0D%0A%0D%0AStudents+need+different+levels+of+autonomy+according+to+ability+and+++context.+In+language+classrooms%2C+providing+opportunities+for+learners+to+++choose+tools%2C+content%2C+pace%2C+and+group+composition+can+also+provide++for++different+learning+styles%2C+language+proficiency+levels%2C+and++interests.++Computers+can+provide+an+array+of+choices+and+methods+of++engagement.+For++example%2C+students+can+have+access+to+a+variety+of++audiences+through+the++Internet.+They+can+learn+grammar+in+a+multitude++of+ways+with+a+variety++of+tools%2C+from+taking+online+quizzes+to+talking++with+fluent+speakers+in++voice+chatrooms+to+reading+and+interacting+with++authentic+texts.+++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22paragraph%22%3E%0D%0A+++++%3Ch4%3E%0D%0A3.+Simple+and+intuitive%3C%2Fh4%3E%0D%0A%0D%0A%3Cul%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3ERoutines%2C+predictability%2C+consistency%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EEffective+prompting+and+feedback%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3ENo+unnecessary+complexity%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Ful%3E%0D%0A%0D%0AIn+language+classrooms%2C+facilitations+such+as+scaffolds%2C+consistent+++structure%2C+models%2C+and+%E2%80%9Cteacher+talk%E2%80%9D+simplify+and+make+instruction+more+++accessible+to+learners.+In+CALL+materials%2C+simple+and+consistent+++software+interfaces%2C+content-based+immediate+feedback%2C+strategy+prompts%2C+++and+other+helps+provide+access+to+diverse+learners+++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22paragraph%22%3E%0D%0A+++++%3Ch4%3E%0D%0A4.+Perceptible+information%2Finformation+access+in+multiple++settings%3C%2Fh4%3E%0D%0A%0D%0A%3Cul%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EVarious+methods+of+representation%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3ERedundant+methods+of+representation%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EVarious+methods+of+expression%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EUse+of+prior+knowledge%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EEssential+information+pointed+out%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Ful%3E%0D%0A%0D%0ASocial+interaction+is+a+crucial+factor+in+both+UID+and+language+learning++environments+because+during+the+negotiation+of+meaning+learners+can+tap++prior+knowledge%2C+focus+on+pertinent+information%2C+and+use+both++linguistic+and+pragmatic+expression.+Learners+can+be+engaged+in+language++focusing+on+discrete+forms+or+engaging+in+authentic+discourse%2C+but++perceptible++access+means+that+learners+have+opportunities+to+understand++in+ways+that+they+do+so+well+and+also+to+express+themselves+in++different+ways.+Computer++technologies+support+these+conditions+in+many++ways.+For+example%2C+hotwords%2C++hyperlinks%2C+and+visuals+can+help+learners++to+discriminate+what+is+important+and+to+access+that+information.+In++many+software+programs%2C+such+as+electronic+encyclopedias%2C+learners+can++see+redundancies+in+text+and+other+media++that+help+them+to+comprehend++both+language+and+content.+In+addition%2C++Web-based+activities+such+as++WebQuests+can+build+on+learners%27+prior+knowledge+to+help+them+to+access++the+language+and+content+of+the+information++presented.+++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22paragraph%22%3E%0D%0A+++++%3Ch4%3E%0D%0A5.+Tolerance+for+error%3C%2Fh4%3E%0D%0A%0D%0A%3Cul%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EAccommodates+learner+pace+and+knows+where+they+are%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EOverlooks%2Fminimizes+unimportant+errors%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3ESupports+student+intentional+cognition%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EEasy+to+navigate%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EMinimal+chance+of+problems+from+accidents+during+use%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Ful%3E%0D%0A%0D%0ALike+UID%2C+CALL+environment+conditions+underscore+the+importance+of+++understanding+learners%27+needs%2C+of+focusing+on+central+issues+and+ideas++rather+than++mistakes%2C+and+helping+learners+to+focus+on+and+think++carefully+about+their++learning.+Computer+technologies+can+help+meet++this+condition+in+many+ways.+For++example%2C+computer-adaptive+testing++accommodates+learners+by+presenting+test+items+according+to+the++learners%27+response+patterns%2C+thereby+individualizing++the+testing++process.+In+addition%2C+software+such+as+Brain+Cogs+%28Fablevision%2C+2002%29++assists+learners+in+reflecting+on+and+developing+their+repertoire+of++metacognitive+strategies.+++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22paragraph%22%3E%0D%0A+++++%3Ch4%3E%0D%0A6.+Physical+access%3C%2Fh4%3E%0D%0A%0D%0A%3Cul%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3ELow+physical+effort%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EAppropriate+size+and+position%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EConsideration+of+communication+needs%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EMaximum+attention+to+learning%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EClear+line+of+sight%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3ETools+accessible+for+all+learners%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Ful%3E%0D%0A%0D%0AIn+CALL%2C+software+that+has+a+simple%2C+consistent+interface+with+both+text++and+visual+components+means+that+learners%27+efforts+can+focus+on+content++and+language+rather+than+the+format+of+the+instruction.+Although+++physical+access+issues+are+not+as+prominent+in+language+environments+as++in%2C+for+example%2C+special+education+classrooms%2C+creating+effective++physical++spaces+in+computer+labs+and+around+other+technologies+is++central+to+creating++optimal+classroom+learning+environments.+++++%0D%0AThis+brief+comparison+shows+that+following+guidelines+for+UID+at+all+++levels+of+language+classrooms+and+in+different+language-learning+++contexts+is+very+similar+to+adhering+to+principles+for+creating+++effective+CALL+environments.+The+strong+intersection+between+UID+and+++CALL+points+to+places+where+we+might+concentrate+our+focus%3B+future+++research+may+be+able+to+determine+the+impact+of+these+conditions+on+++language+and+content+learning.+Clearly%2C+computer+technologies+can+assist+++teachers+and+learners+in+creating+accessible+learning+environments+for+++language+learners.+Examples+of+ways+to+incorporate+UID+conditions+in+++CALL+classrooms+are+provided+below.+++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22chapter%22%3E%0D%0A++++%3Ch3%3E%0D%0ATools+and+techniques+to+support+UID+in+CALL+classrooms%3C%2Fh3%3E%0D%0ABowe++%282000%29%2C+Burgstahler+%282002%29%2C+the+Council+for+Exceptional+Children+++%281999%29%2C+Hatfield+%26amp%3B+Fox+%282002%29%2C+Izzo+%282002%29%2C+Shaw%2C+Scott%2C+%26amp%3B++McGuire++%282001%29%2C+and+others+provide+many+examples+of+useful+ways+to++implement+UID+in++classrooms%2C+including+effective+seating+arrangements%2C++participant+structures%2C+tools%2C+and+techniques.+Strehorn+%282001%29+provides++specific+ideas+for+integrating+UID+principles+in+language+classrooms.++These+include%3A++++%0D%0A%3Cul%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3Etaping+classroom+lectures+and+interactions+not+only+for+extra+++listening+practice+but+to+provide+review+for+students+who+need+support+++for+listening%3C%2Fli%3E% D%0A%3Cli%3Ehaving+a+variety+of+resources%2C+including+dictionaries%2C+available++to+learners%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3Ehaving+the+syllabus+and+other+course+documents+available+in+many++formats%2C+including+paper%2C+electronic%2C+and+oversized%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3Eusing+books+on+tape%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3Eproviding+students+with+notes+from+classes%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3Ereading+documents+out+loud%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3Esupplying+time+frames+and+clear+rubrics+for+assignments%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3Eallowing+choices+for+ways+in+which+students+respond+to++assignments%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Ful%3E%0D%0A%0D%0AThe+Council+for+Exceptional+Children+%281999%29%2C+Shaw%2C+et+al+%282001%29+and+++Silver%2C+Bourke%2C+%26amp%3B+Strehorn+%281998%29+point+out+that+the+use+of++information+and+communication+technologies+can+facilitate+the++integration+of+UID++conditions+into+the+curriculum%2C+as+noted+in+many+of++the+examples+above.+In+language+classrooms+these+technologies%2C+including++audio+and+video+recorders+and+players%2C+computers%2C+and+digital+cameras%2C++allow+teachers+to+incorporate+cueing%2C+organizers%2C+multi-modal++instruction+and+modeling%2C+as+well+as+to+support+interaction.+Technology++can+assist+with+the+transfer+of++text-based+information+to+a+visual++format+%28i.e.%2C+through+graphics+or+video%29+or++audio+format%2C+and+vice++versa.+Oklahoma+State+University+provides+links+and++information+for++using+technology+to+meet+UID+principles+%28see+%3Ca+href%3D%22http%3A%2F%2Fwww.okstate.edu%2Fucs%2Fstdis%2Fweb.html%22+target%3D%22_blank%22%3Ehttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.okstate.edu%2Fucs%2Fstdis%2Fweb.html%3C%2Fa%3E%29.+++++%0D%0AThere+are+other+tools+to+help+language+students+with+diverse+abilities%2C+++from+gifted+students+to+those+with+interrupted+schooling+to+those+with+++physical+impairments.++Bowe+%282000%29+mentions+EReader+by+CAST+%28%3Ca+href%3D%22http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cast.org%2F%22+target%3D%22_blank%22%3Ehttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.cast.org%3C%2Fa%3E%29%2C+++which+allows+students+to+control+features+of+text+such+as+use+of++voice%2C++highlighting%2C+and+the+font+size+of+the+text.+Software+packages++that++offer+study+guides%2C+previews%2C+and+tutorials+also+help+to+support+++learning+by+students+with+diverse+abilities.+Whichever+tools+are+used%2C+++it+is+important+that+they+not+only+assist+learners+in+meeting+objectives+++but+that+they+allow+all+learners+to+participate+as+fully+as+they+need+++or+want+to+in+the+process.++++%0D%0AFigure+1+presents+a+generic+content-based+lesson+and+the+UID+conditions%2C+++tools%2C+and+techniques+that+make+it+more+accessible+to+all+learners+in+a+++CALL+classroom.++++%0D%0A%0D%0AFigure+1%3A+UID+conditions+in+a+CALL+activity%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3ETheme%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+U.S.+Culture%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3ECourse%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+Intermediate+ESL+%28content-based%29%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3EDuration+and+format+of+activity%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A++Approximately+one+hour+per+day%2C+2-3+weeks%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3EStudents%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+14+young+adult+students+at+varied+++levels+of+proficiency+in+the+skills+areas%2C+five+different+language+and+++culture+backgrounds%2C+varying+lengths+of+stay+in+the+U.S.%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3ESample+Language+and+Content+Objectives%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A%0D%0AAt+the+end+of+this+activity%2C+students+will+be+able+to%0D%0A%3Cul%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EDescribe+aspects+of+U.S.+culture+using+appropriate+vocabulary+and++structures%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3ECreate+and+ask+original+questions%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EWork+with+teammates+appropriately%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EExplain+a+multimedia+presentation+of+their+work%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Ful%3E%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3ETESOL+Standards+focus%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+%28from+TESOL%2C+Inc%2C++1997%29%0D%0A2.1++Use+English+to+communicate+in+academic+settings%0D%0A2.2++Use+English+to+obtain%2C+process%2C+construct%2C+and+provide+subject++matter+information+in+spoken+and%2For+written+form%0D%0A3.1+Use+the+appropriate+language+variety%2C+register%2C+and+genre++according+to+audience%2C+purpose%2C+and+setting%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3EPresentation%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+Days+1+and+2%2C+Project++preparation%0D%0AStep+1%3A%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3EOriginal+Lesson%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+Teacher+starts+by++presenting+an+overview+of+U.S.+culture.%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3EUID+Lesson%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+Teacher+starts+by+tapping++studentsq%C2%AB%C2%81prior+knowledge+and+engaging+their+attention.%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3ETools+and+Techniques%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+Teacher+and+students+++discuss+why+it+is+important+for+them+to+learn+about+U.S.+culture.++Students+start+by+telling+what+they+already+know+about++U.S.+culture.++Students+have+had+time+to+prepare+by+writing%2C+speaking%2C+or++drawing.+As++students+discuss%2C+the+teacher+lists+all+the+%22facts%22+on+the+board+or++overhead+and+also+speaks+them+aloud%2C+recording+the+list+as+she+goes.+She++also+posts+student+drawings+as+appropriate.+She+gives+students+time+to++respond+to+each+other+and+provides+feedback+such+as+asking+for+more++information+on+the+ideas.+Students+decide+which+they+believe+are++actual++characteristics+of+U.S.+culture%2C+and+these+are+listed+on+one+side+of++the+bulletin+board+in+large+text+with+pictures+beside+them+where++possible.%0D%0AStep+2%3A%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3EOriginal+Lesson%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+Students+pick+out+++characteristics+of+U.S.+culture+from+a+social+studies+textbook+and+the+++teacher+writes+them+on+the+board.+The+teacher+tells+students+whether+++they+are+right+or+wrong.+Students+copy+the+completed+list.%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3EUID+lesson%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+Students+have+a+variety+of+++readings+and+resources%2C+including+a+content-based+textbook%2C+video+clips%2C+++and+the+Web%2C+from+which+to+find+different+ideas+about+U.S.+culture.%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3ETools+and+Techniques%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+In+some+of+the++readings++the+teacher+has+highlighted+essential+information.+She+goes++through++one+reading%2C+including+reading+it+aloud%2C+to+model+how+to+find+++information.+Students+can+choose+the+reading%28s%29+they+want+to+use+and+++whether+to+work+together+or+alone.+The+characteristics+they+find+can+be+++copied%2C+spoken+out+loud%2C+or+sketched+out+for+presentation+to+the+class.+++Students+explain+what+they+found+using+guiding+questions+from+the+++teacher.+The+completed+list+is+copied+by+the+students%2C+posted+on+the+++bulletin+board+in+the+classroom%2C+and+recorded+on+videotape.%0D%0AStep+3%3A%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3EOriginal+lesson%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+Students+write+a+summary%2C+++describing+what+they+think+are+the+five+most+important+aspects+of+U.S.+++culture.+They+read+their+summaries+to+the+class+one+by+one.%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3EUID+lesson%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+Teacher+explains+that+students+++will+have+a+project+to+find+out+more+about+U.S.+culture.+Students+have+++choices+of+how+to+complete+the+activity+and+with+whom+to+complete+it.+++They+use+readings+and+templates+from+Cultural+Reporter+%28Falk%2C+1995%29+and+++other+scaffolds+to+find+out+about+an+aspect+of+U.S.+culture+that+is+++relevant+to+them.+Some+of+the+Asian+students+want+to+explore+home+visit+++customs%2C+the+Thai+students+decide+to+work+on+the+relationship+between+++their+school+and+the+town%2C+some+students+want+to+investigate+what+U.S.+++students+think+about+non-native+English+speakers%2C+and+the+remaining+++groups+choose+other+topics.++Tools+and+Techniques%3A+Students+form+small++groups+around+their+topic+and++cooperatively+decide+on+roles+and++responsibilities+for+data+collection++and+analysis%2C+including+creating++survey+questions%2C+finding+interview++subjects%2C+conducting+Web-based++research%2C+and+whatever+other+procedures++they+need.+Together+students++decide+on+a+format+and+tools+for+presenting++their+final+project.%0D%0AStep+4%3A%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3EOriginal+lesson%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+Students+hand+in+the++summary+before+the+end+of+class.%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3EUID+lesson%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+Students+and+teacher+discuss++the++process%2C+including+roles+that+each+student+will+play+and+individual+++goals+for+each+learner.+Students+and+teacher+negotiate+the+timing+and+++feedback+necessary+to+complete+the+project+and+meet+the+language+and+++content+goals.%0D%0A%3Cspan+class%3D%22bold%22%3ETools+and+Techniques%3C%2Fspan%3E%3A+The+teacher+asks+each+++group+to+develop+a+timeline+for+the+project+using+multimedia%2Fbilingual++timeliner+software+%28such+as+that+offered+by+Tom++Snyder+Productions+at+%3Ca+href%3D%22http%3A%2F%2Fwww.tomsnyder.com%2FProducts%2Fproduct.asp%3FSKU%3DTIMV50%22+target%3D%22_blank%22%3Ehttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.tomsnyder.com%2FProducts%2Fproduct.asp%3FSKU%3DTIMV50%3C%2Fa%3E%29+++and+show%2Ftell+her+how+long+they+think+it+will+take+them+to+complete.++Later+she+will+assign+a+due+date%2Ftime+based+on+negotiations+with+the+++teams.%0D%0ADuring+group+time+over+the+next+two+weeks+of+the++project%2C+the+teacher++can+offer+or+suggest+grammar+and+discrete+skills++practice+and+provide++feedback+as+necessary.+Although+there+are+many++ways+to+implement+UID%2C++the+lesson+in+Figure+1+demonstrates+that++relatively+simple+modifications++can+be+made+to+support+environments++that+incorporate+the+conditions.+By++providing+students+with+choices%2C++the+instructor+can+help+students+work++to+their+strengths%2C+both+in++content+and+language.+By+offering+tools+and++materials+that+have++accessible+built-in+help+features%2C+the+teacher++creates+a+climate+of++challenge+while+ensuring+that+the+goals+are++achievable.+Language+skills++are+developed+not+only+through+drill+but++through+authentic+practice.++Most+important%2C+in+UID+and+effective+CALL++classrooms%2C+opportunities+to++use+computer+tools+are+ubiquitous+but+not++required%2C+and+when+used+the++tools+are+supportive%2C+goal-oriented%2C+and++under+the+control+of+the++learner.++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22chapter%22%3E%0D%0A++++%3Ch3%3E%0D%0ABarriers+to+implementing+UID+in+CALL+classrooms%3C%2Fh3%3E%0D%0AThere++are%2C+however%2C+barriers+to+implementing+UID+in+CALL+classrooms.+For+++example%2C+if+the+goal+of+a+course+or+lesson+were+text-based+literacy%2C+++then+testing+with+a+voice+option+would+not+offer+an+effective+++assessment.+Or%2C+if+the+objective+were+oral+fluency%2C+it+may+not+be+useful+++for+learners+to+answer+questions+in+other+modes.+However%2C+many+of+the+++UID+conditions+can+still+be+implemented+in+such+lessons.++++%0D%0AAnother+barrier+to+implementing+UID+in+CALL+classrooms+is+the+time+it+++takes+to+make+sure+that+all+learners+have+access%3B+whether+the+time+and++effort+spent+on+such+preparation+is+feasible+is+a+question+that+must+be+++answered.+Not+only+must+the+technology+be+carefully+explored+to+ensure++that+it++meets+the+conditions%2C+but+so+must+all+other+aspects+of+the++instruction.+Silver+et.+al.+%281998%29%2C+however%2C+argue+that+modifications+to++the+syllabus%2C++materials%2C+and+instructional+delivery+methods+%22...+would++eventually+save+time+once+they+become+routine%22+%28p.+49%29.+Teachers+need++to+decide+if+the+time+spent+is+worth+the+gains.++++%0D%0AA+final%2C+but+perhaps+more+significant%2C+barrier+to+implementing+UID+++principles+in+CALL+classrooms+is+the+potential+conflicting+and+complex+++needs+of+learners+from+many+different+cultural+backgrounds.+The+special+++demands+put+upon+language+teachers+by+learners+with+widely+varying+++values%2C+learning+styles%2C+and+backgrounds+pose+special+issues+for+the+++implementation+of+conditions+that+give+everyone+access+to+the+++instruction+and+supportive+technologies.+As+we+discover+more+about+how+++UID+and+CALL+environment+conditions+work+in+classrooms%2C+we+may+be+able+++to+more+effectively+address+this+barrier.++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22chapter%22%3E%0D%0A++++%3Ch3%3E%0D%0AConclusion%3C%2Fh3%3E%0D%0AFrom+this+brief++discussion+it+is+evident+that+UID+environment+conditions+are+not+that++different+from+conditions+that+effective+language+teachers+already++create+in+their+instructional+environments.+This+overlap+may++seem+to++make+the+discussion+of+UID+in+CALL+redundant%2C+but+there+are+several++important+reasons+to+continue+this+discussion.+First%2C+defining+UID+gives++us+a+place+to+%22hang+our+hats%22+by+providing+a+way+to+talk+easily+about++the+concept+and+to+develop+a+common+understanding+not+only+within+the++language+field+but+with+others+in+different+areas+of+education+and+in++other+fields.+Second%2C+discussing+the+concept+and+relating+it+to+what+we++already+know+leads+to+the+ability+to+ask+more+critical+questions+and++conduct+research+in+this+area.+We+can+also+view+on-going+research+on+++language+classrooms+through+the+dual+lens+of+UID%2F+CALL+environment++conditions++without+taking+away+from+principles+of+either.+Finally%2C+by++providing+an+outside+view+of+what+we+as+teachers+know+and+do%2C+this++discussion+can+help+us%2C+as+Strehorn+%282001%29+suggests%2C+%22...+to+implement++new+and+useful+course+design+and+teaching+techniques+to+allow+more++access+to+the+information+being+taught%22+%28p.+3%29+in+CALL+classrooms.++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22chapter%22%3E%0D%0A++++%3Ch3%3E%0D%0AAuthor%3C%2Fh3%3E%0D%0AJoy+Egbert+is+Assistant++Professor+of+ESL+and+Technology+and+Director+of++the+Training+for+All++Teachers+grant+program+at+Washington+State++University%2C+Pullman.+Her++research+and+teaching+interests+include+on-line++professional++development%2C+teacher+education%2C+and+CALL+theory+and++practice.+Home++Page%3A+%3Ca+href%3D%22http%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsu.edu%2F%257Eegbert%2F%2F%22+target%3D%22_blank%22%3Ehttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsu.edu%2F%7Eegbert%2F%3C%2Fa%3E++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22reference%22%3E%0D%0A++++%3Ch3%3E%0D%0AReferences%3C%2Fh3%3E%0D%0A%3Cul%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EBowe%2C+F.+%282000%29.+%3Cspan+class%3D%22italic%22%3EUniversal+Design+in++education%3A+Teaching+non-traditional+students%3C%2Fspan%3E.+Westport%2C+CT%3A++Bergin+%26amp%3B+Garvey.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EBrain+Cogs+%282002%29.+%3Cspan+class%3D%22italic%22%3EComputer+Software%3C%2Fspan%3E.++Watertown%2C+MA%3A+Fablevision.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EBurgstahler%2C+S.+%282002%29.+Universal+Design+of+Instruction.++Available%3A+%3Ca+href%3D%22http%3A%2F%2Fwww.washington.edu%2Fdoit%2FBrochures%2FAcademics%2Finstruction.html%22+target%3D%22_blank%22%3Ehttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.washington.edu%2Fdoit%2FBrochures%2FAcademics%2Finstruction.html%3C%2Fa%3E++%5BAccessed+November+6%2C+2003%5D%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EConnell%2C+B.%2C+Jones%2C+M.%2C+Mace%2C+R.%2C+Mueller%2C+J.%2C+Mullick%2C+A.%2C+++Ostroff%2C+E.%2C+++Sanford%2C+J.+Steinfield%2C+E.%2C+Story%2C+M.+%26amp%3B+Vanderheiden%2C++G.+%281997%29.+%3Cspan+class%3D%22italic%22%3EThe+principles+of+universal+design+%28Version+2.0%29%3C%2Fspan%3E.++Available%3A+%3Ca+href%3D%22http%3A%2F%2Fwww.design.ncsu.edu%3A8120%2Fcud%2Funiv_design%2Fprinciples%2Fudprinciples.htm%22+target%3D%22_blank%22%3Ehttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.design.ncsu.edu%3A8120%2Fcud%2Funiv_design%2Fprinciples%2Fudprinciples.htm%3C%2Fa%3E++%5BAccessed+November+6%2C+2003%5D%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3ECouncil+for+Exceptional+Children+%281999%29.+A+curriculum+every++student++can+++use%3A+Design+principles+for+student+access.+ERIC+Clearinghouse+on+++Disabilities+++and+Gifted+Education.+Available%3A+%3Ca+href%3D%22http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cec.sped.org%2Fosep%2Fud-sec4.html%22+target%3D%22_blank%22%3Ehttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.cec.sped.org%2Fosep%2Fud-sec4.html%3C%2Fa%3E++%5BAccessed+November+6%2C+2003%5D%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EEgbert%2C+J.%2C+Hanson-Smith%2C+E.%2C+%26amp%3B+Chao%2C+C.+%281999%29.+Chapter+1.+%3Cspan+class%3D%22italic%22%3ECALL+environments%3A+Research%2C+practice%2C+and+critical++issues%3C%2Fspan%3E.+Alexandria%2C+VA%3A+TESOL%2C+Inc.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EFalk%2C+L.+%281995%29.+%3Cspan+class%3D%22italic%22%3ECultural+Reporter%3A++Reporter%27s+Handbook%3C%2Fspan%3E.+Washington%2C+DC%3A+Smithsonian+Institution.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EHatfield%2C+J.+%26amp%3B+Fox%2C+J.+%282001%29.+Universal+Instructional+Design+++in+postsecondary+++education.+Paper+presented+at+the+2002+Annual+Meeting++of+the+U.S.++Educational+++Research+Association%2C+New+Orleans.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EIzzo%2C+M.+%282002%29.+Fast+facts+for+faculty%3A+Universal+Design+for++learning.+Available%3A+%3Ca+href%3D%22http%3A%2F%2Fwww.acs.ohio-state.edu%2Fgrants%2Fdpg%2Ffastfact%2Fundesign.html%22+target%3D%22_blank%22%3Ehttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.acs.ohio-state.edu%2Fgrants%2Fdpg%2Ffastfact%2Fundesign.html%3C%2Fa%3E++%5BAccessed+November+6%2C+2003%5D%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3ELarsen-Freeman%2C+D.+%281997%29.+Chaos%2Fcomplexity+science+and+second++language+acquisition.+%3Cspan+class%3D%22italic%22%3EApplied+Linguistics%3C%2Fspan%3E%2C++18%282%29%2C+141-165.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EShaw%2C+S.%2C+Scott%2C+S.%2C+McGuire%2C+J.+%282001%29.+Teaching+college+students+++with+learning+disabilities.+ERIC+Clearinghouse+on+Disabilities+and+++Gifted+Education%2C+Council+for+Exceptional+Children.+ERIC+EC+Digest+++%23E618.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3ESilver%2C+P.%2C+Bourke%2C+A.+%26amp%3B+Strehorn%2C+K.+%281998%29.+Universal+++Instructional+++Design+in+higher+education%3A+An+approach+for+inclusion.+%3Cspan+class%3D%22italic%22%3EEquity+and+Excellence+in+Education%3C%2Fspan%3E%2C+31%282%29.+47-51.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3EStrehorn%2C+K.+%282001%29.+The+application+of+Universal+Instructional++Design+to+ESL+teaching.+%3Cspan+class%3D%22italic%22%3EInternet+TESL+Journal%3C%2Fspan%3E.++Available%3A+%3Ca+href%3D%22http%3A%2F%2Fiteslj.org%2FTechniques%2FStrehorn-UID.html%22+target%3D%22_blank%22%3Ehttp%3A%2F%2Fiteslj.org%2FTechniques%2FStrehorn-UID.html%3C%2Fa%3E++%5BAccessed+November+6%2C+2003%5D%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3Cli%3ETESOL%2C+Inc.+%281997%29.+%3Cspan+class%3D%22italic%22%3EESL+standards+for+Pre++K-12+students%3C%2Fspan%3E.+Alexandria%2C+VA%3A+Author.%3C%2Fli%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Ful%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv%3E%0D%0Asource%3A+http%3A%2F%2Fcallej.org%2F%26nbsp%3B%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22chapter%22%3E%0D%0A++++%3Ch3%3E%0D%0AAcknowledgement%3C%2Fh3%3E%0D%0AThe+author+wishes+to+thank+Gina+Mikel+Petrie+foN+assistance+with+this++manuscript.++++%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A%3Cdiv+class%3D%22copyright%22%3E%0D%0A+Copyright+%28c%29+2004-+Joy+L.+Egbert+%26amp%3B+CALL-EJ+Online+%28ISSN+1442-438X%29.++All+rights+reserved.++%3C%2Fdiv%3E%0D%0A

Collaborative Interaction in EFL Web-Based Debates: How Do Learners Develop Socially Constructed Knowledge?

Collaborative Interaction in EFL Web-Based Debates: How Do Learners Develop Socially Constructed Knowledge?

  • ISSN 1442-438X
  • CALL-EJ Online
  • Vol. 5, No. 2, January 2004

Abstract

This paper focuses on interactions between Japanese learners of English as a foreign language using computer-mediated communication (CMC) in the second language (L2) classroom. CMC provides potential benefits for L2 learning because it enables a broader range of interaction. In this study, a synchronous on-line debate was conducted using a Bulletin Board System (BBS). Interactions through the on-line debates were analyzed based on Gunawardena, Lowe and Anderson's (1997) “Interaction Analysis Model” for examining social construction of knowledge. Based on their methods and theory of social constructivism, an investigation was made on how the on-line interactions could be qualitatively assessed, and on whether negotiations between the participants would generate construction of knowledge. In this paper two representative debate logs were analyzed to scrutinize how knowledge was co-constructed through social interaction. The value of debates for pedagogical use was also reconsidered, and new criteria for the debate evaluation were proposed.

Introduction

The main purpose of this paper is to qualitatively analyze CMC based interactions between Japanese learners of English as a foreign language (EFL). While there have been some studies on CMC in L2 settings conducted, very few studies have explored the quality of L2 learning through CMC. The major purpose of this study, thus, is to conduct a qualitative analysis of on-line debates in L2 settings.
In this research, synchronous on-line debates are conducted using a BBS. In particular, this paper focuses on the interactions in the on-line debates, because debates by their nature allow the participants to express different points of view, which would be assumed to facilitate active interactions between the debaters. It is further conceived that participants' learning will be deepened in the active interaction.
In order to obtain an analytical model and evaluation methods for this study, the “Interaction Analysis Model” by Gunawardena, Lowe and Anderson (1997) is of particular interest here. Based on the methods used in their study of social construction of knowledge in computer conferencing, the greater part of this paper is devoted to the examinations of on-line debates between Japanese EFL learners and the co-construction of knowledge observed in the debates.

A review of previous literature

Some characteristics of CMC in L2 settings

Studies which compare face-to-face interaction and CMC reported that CMC has several benefits for language learning. For example, CMC demands no turn taking competition (Kitade, 2000), provides for more equal participation (Beauvois, 1992; Chun, 1994; Kelm, 1992; Kern, 1995) and allows shy and less motivated learners to interact with others (Beauvois, 1992; Kelm, 1992). Another advantage is that the learner re-examines and edits the text-based communication to make the interaction more meaningful and comprehensible. In other words, learners are more aware of the language structures that they and their peers use to compose messages (Lee, 2002). Subsequently, this may lead them to attend to feedback or attempt frequent self-correction. Learners benefit from a focus on form (Lightbown & Pienemann, 1993; Pica, 1996) in attempting to overcome incorrect target language features. This internal monitor facilitates language acquisition.
Other studies indicate that CMC enables learners to increase their language production and complexity because the participation structure is significantly different from a typical classroom interaction (Chun, 1994; Kern, 1995). For example, a reduction of teacher talk in CMC is a benefit of learners' language production. Learner-learner on-line interaction, therefore, should result in greater language production than that achieved in teacher-learner interaction. Other studies show that on-line interaction in language learning not only supports the development of students' language skills but also fosters students' interest and motivation in language learning in general (Cononelos & Oliva, 1993; Warschauer, 1996).
Those observations are the fruit from the studies of CMC in L2 settings. However, very few studies have been conducted to make a qualitative assessment of L2 CMC interaction. Therefore, in this paper, the qualitative aspects of the interaction by EFL learners will be focused on.

Gunawardena, Lowe and Andersons' Model (1997) (See Appendix 1)

Gunawardena, et al. developed the “Interaction Analysis Model” for examining social construction of knowledge in computer conferencing. They conducted a global on-line debate and analyzed the logs obtained from it. The purpose of their study was to develop an assessment system of the quality of interactions and the quality of the learning experience in a computer-mediated conferencing which has not been satisfactorily investigated.
Their research was based on the studies by Garrison (1991), Henri (1991), and Newman, et al.'s (1995) models. They pointed out, however, that previous studies did not fully examine how to evaluate the process of knowledge construction that occurs through social negotiation in CMC. Moreover, they stated that the definitions of interaction in the models employed were “either unclear, or not very applicable to the pattern of interaction observed in the debate.” (p. 402)
What is social constructivism? There are several theoretical positions on social constructivism in academic circles. Some of them are based on Vygotsky's social development theory. Vygotsky (1978) states, “Every function in the child's cultural development appears twice: first, on the social level, and later, on the individual level; first, between people (inter psychological) and then inside the child (intra psychological).” (p. 57)
He stresses the influence of cultural and social contexts in learning and he holds the view that learning first takes place in interaction between two people (inter psychological) before it becomes a mental process for the individual (intra psychological). In this research CMC is used for on-line debate, because CMC is thought to provide an appropriate environment which supports collaboration and social interaction. Collaboration occurs when learners share others' views and they make a coordinated effort to solve problems together. Collaboration can increase social interaction and social interaction can develop the construction of knowledge, which leads to improved learning outcomes and promote deep learning. Based on the social constructivist theory, Gunawardena, et al. developed a constructivist model of CMC interaction, which is visualized in Figure 1. Each piece represents contributions by one or more persons based on experience, research, theory, etc.

Figure 1: A constructivist model of CMC interaction (Gunawardena, et al., 1997: 411)

Gunawardena et al.'s Interaction Analysis Model, which encompasses five phases and qualitatively assesses CMC interactions, is based on the criteria described in Appendix 1. By elaborating the model, it can be applied to this study as an analytical tool. Gunawardena et al. could confirm that their Interaction Analysis Model enabled them to provide the means to determine that knowledge construction occurred within a group through interaction among participants.

Research

Gunawardena, et al. conducted an on-line debate in an L1 setting, in which most of the participants were teachers and graduate students who were involved in distance education. By using the “Interaction Analysis Model”, they confirmed that the co-creation of knowledge and negotiation of meaning had occurred in the process of interaction. In the present study, I will look at how I conducted on-line debates between Japanese learners of English and analyze the interactions using Gunawardena et al.'s “Interaction Analysis Model”. I am particularly concerned with how the interaction can be qualitatively assessed and whether negotiation between the participants will bring about construction of knowledge.

Purpose of the Research

The most distinguishing feature of this study is to qualitatively examine how learners of English develop the social construction of knowledge through CMC. This study provides a qualitative analysis of the CMC interaction between NNSs in an e-learning context. I understand that the effectiveness of CMC is brought about when it is used in tele-collaboration, in which the participants are located in different places and work together through CMC. In this research, however, each pair is requested to sit in the same room and to join in the debates. Although the conditions under which this study was conducted may have affected the interaction among the participants, the learning environment presented here, I assume, is the one which is accessible in ordinary school settings. In addition, the bottom line is how we use the computers. According to Chun (1994), “what computers can facilitate though, is human interaction among people in the same room as well as continents apart.” (p. 17)

Procedures

Experimental research on on-line debates between Japanese EFL learners of English was carried out. Using a web-based debate interface, which was originally developed for this study, how Japanese learners of English develop a social construction of knowledge through CMC was investigated. Three pairs of university students learning English as a foreign language participated in six debates and each of the pairs exchanged messages around the propositions presented by posting messages on a BBS. Two debate logs are chosen here to scrutinize how the participants construct their knowledge as a result of the interaction.

Tasks and participants

Synchronous on-line debates through BBS were carried out in June, 2002. Six students2 (four females and two males), whose ages range from 19 to 22, voluntarily participated in the research. All were undergraduate students enrolled in a general English course at the Hyogo University of Teacher Education, and all sessions were not related to their academic results. All participants were native speakers of Japanese and had been learning English for more than seven years. There were seven sessions in total, and each session lasted for about 90 minutes. Some portions of the second-grade level of STEP (the Society for Testing English Proficiency) test were administered in the first session to evaluate their English proficiency. The maximum score was 50 points, and their results were as follows: A:40, B: 28, C:24, D:24, E:22, F:35.
To ensure that all learners would feel comfortable using the computers, practice sessions were conducted before data collection began. Therefore, the first topic in the debate was omitted from the data analysis of this research. The participants were paired throughout the sessions according to their schedule availability.
The following six propositions were used for the debates
  • Cellular phones use should be banned in public places.
  • English should not be included in the entrance examination.
  • English should be taught in every primary school.
  • Telephone is better than e-mail.
  • Juku (cram schools) should be abolished.
  • Campus should be downtown.

All the participants were given the propositions in advance and they also knew which side (affirmative or negative) they had to take. They were required to prepare their opinions as constructive arguments for each proposition in English. In the session, twenty minutes were allotted for writing the constructive arguments on the BBS. The first rebuttal argument was always started from the con side, but in the first few sessions, the participants were confused and did not follow the rule. After posting their constructive arguments, they started exchanging their rebuttal arguments for about 50 to 60 minutes.

Interface on the web site

I developed the original interface using a web, as shown in Figure 2. The web browser displays three windows. The left window shows the information which helps the participants construct their opinions. In the right window, the BBS, the participants post their messages. The top window shows several icons, each of which is linked to an on-line dictionary, word lists and useful expressions for debates, and search engines.

Figure 2. Original interface

Use of on-line scaffoldings

In this research three on-line “scaffolding” devices were prepared to facilitate the interaction. The idea of scaffolding is often referred to by educational psychologists who advocate Vygotskyan approaches to learning and teaching. This approach is concerned with learning in which a social interaction between an expert and a novice takes place. In this situation an expert or a teacher first jointly do most of the tasks with the child. Gradually, however, the child becomes able to handle the tasks on his own and the teacher's temporary supports are removed until they are no longer necessary. The supportive action by the teacher is called “scaffolding” (Newman, Griffin and Cole, 1989). I assumed the on-line devices I designed on the web page would support the participants to do the tasks and would be less frequently used when they became more competent debaters. The devices included a list of useful expressions for debates, glossaries and an on-line dictionary.
A collection of useful expressions for the debate could be accessed from one of the icons allotted at the top of the window. Some basic and frequently used expressions for debating were listed and the participants were able to organize effective text structures by making use of them. Moreover, using useful expressions seemed to help to make a natural flow of argument.
Next, I will explain how the on-line dictionary was used by the participants. The on-line dictionary is a very strong tool for language learners. One of the advantages of using an on-line dictionary is that an entry found in the Japanese-English dictionary can be instantly switched into the English-Japanese one. With this process we can check whether the English word found in the dictionary is equivalent to the Japanese counterpart.

Data analysis

The data was analyzed focusing on the interactions based on the “Interaction Analysis Model” by Gunawardena, et al. (1997).

A) Inter-rater reliability

To analyze the interaction qualitatively, two raters independently evaluated every log posted in the BBS based on the “Interaction Analysis Model” by Gunawardena et al. Both raters had extensive experience in teaching English as a foreign language (EFL) in Japan and understood the “Interaction Analysis Model”. The inter-rater reliability was calculated by coefficient reliability (CR) by Holsti (1969, cited in Garrison, Anderson and Archer, 2001) and kappa (κ) by Cohen (1960).
CR is a percent-agreement measure in which the number of agreements between the first rater and the second rater are divided by the total number of coding decisions. Cohen's kappa is a chance-corrected measure of inter-rater reliability using a computational procedure. The results of the CR of three dyads were .88, .92 and .92 respectively, indicating a high level of agreement between the raters.
In addition to the CR, Cohen's kappa was calculated. According to Cohen, high reliability should range between .80 and .90. The results of kappa were .84, .85 and .81, which indicate a high level of agreement between the raters. (See Appendix 22)

B) Number of each phase

Since the interaction analysis is a nominal evaluation whose characteristics are descriptive and qualitative, there were some debate logs in which it was hard to reach agreement between the two raters. Raters discussed these logs at length until the disagreements were resolved.

Table 1: Numbers of total messages in each phase by each dyad


Table 2: Numbers of Phase III by each dyad


Figure 3: Total numbers of messages in each phase by each dyad

The number of each phase by each dyad is shown in Table 1 and Figure 3. All the constructive arguments were classified into Phase I, and most of the arguments in rebuttal sessions belonged to Phase II, where cognitive dissonance or inconsistencies among ideas were expressed. The debate format seemed to hinder participants from arriving at a compromise or synthesis, but some arguments were able to be classified into Phase III where participants changed their understandings or constNucted new knowledge as a result of interaction. The number of Phase III by each dyad is shown in Table 2. This issue will be dealt with later.

Proposition and development of argument

Unlike ordinary face-to-face debates, about 45% of the constructive arguments posted at the beginning of the debates did not develop into further arguments. For example, in one of the games, the affirmative side posted four constructive arguments but the pair argued only one of them. One of the factors which constrained the on-line debate is time. Fifty to sixty minutes is not enough for the participants to exchange their messages. This clearly restricted the expansion of argument, and, as a result, only a few constructive arguments were developed into a debate.
Another characteristic of our on-line debates which contrasts with ordinary face-to-face debates is that some messages exchanged are classified as Phase III, which is “the compromise or synthesis of the proposition”. In an ordinary debate it is difficult to reach a compromise or a synthesis on the propositions because either side has to present a more convincing argument to win the debate game. However, our data shows new ideas and compromised views emerged in Phase III as a result of social interaction.
By analyzing two debate logs I will examine how knowledge is co-constructed through social interaction. In the following analyses, the English language used by the students has been altered a little for clarity, but not to the extent that the intention of the contributor is changed.

Analysis of debate logs

A) Telephone is better than e-mail. (A vs B) (See Appendix 3)

Both the affirmative and negative sides posted three constructive arguments. Each is classified as Phase I, i.e., “Sharing/comparing of information.” The affirmative side supported the argument and posted three constructive arguments, which were: (1) People can directly understand the feeling of the people on the other side, (2) It is sometimes uncertain whether or not the addressee has received e-mails, and (3) E-mail causes misunderstandings.
The negative side posted three constructive arguments as well, which were: (1) People need not worry about the other party, (2) Words can be chosen more carefully using e-mail, and (3) E-mail is cheaper than the telephone.
Within these six constructive postings the argument was developed around one posted by the affirmative side: “People can directly understand the feeling of those on the other side.” The first posting from the negative side [043]4 was “We also express our feelings by sending e-mail”, which was judged as operation A, Phase II “Identifying and stating areas of disagreement”. From [043] to [045] both sides exchanged messages, which were all judged as “Phase II/A” messages, claiming strengths of the telephone and e-mail. In [046] the affirmative side wrote “Yours is an irrelevant argument. Get back to the main point.” Here the affirmative side controlled the flow of the discourse. The negative side agreed and the argument progressed at the pace of the affirmative side. The affirmative side gave a further argument, “In case of an emergency, would you still want to use e-mail [048]?”, which is classified as “Phase II/B”, “Asking and answering questions to clarify the source and extent of disagreement.” After this posting until [051], both sides argued which medium was more useful or efficient in the case of emergency and all the arguments were judged as Phase II. Then, they went back to one of the arguments, “Which is more affordable?” The affirmative side agreed that the debater accept it as the fact and she seemed to have no intention to argue further about money matters. In [052] she put, “It's true. E-mail is cheaper but when you have many things to talk about, telephone is better [Phase II/A].” In conclusion she added, “Mail can't work in the case of an emergency.” The affirmative side ended up this argument by claiming, “Mail and telephone have their own roles [052].” The argument stopped here but this statement could be accepted by negative side because in the process of argument both sides seemed to have noticed that both e-mail and telephone have their advantages and disadvantages. This is classified as “Phase III”; “Negotiation of meaning/co-construction of knowledge.” In this case it is operation D which is “Proposal and negotiation of new statements embodying compromise, co-construction.” After exchanging their arguments several times, one debater reached the stage of “Phase III”. The message implies that a good discussion about telephone and e-mail could not be held unless the roles of each medium are understood. In an ordinary oral debate this process should be avoided because it is less convincing to propose a compromised argument, but we could say that the participants tried to transform the argument so that they could have an “agreement” as a result of the interaction. We judged this as a co-construction of the new knowledge through social interaction.

B) Telephone is better than e-mail. (C vs D) (See Appendix 4 )

In this session the first messages posted by both sides included six constructive arguments in total [140, 141], which were all classified as “Phase I” i.e., “Sharing/comparing of information”. Throughout the session, however, one constructive argument posted from the affirmative side, “E-Mail causes misunderstanding [140]” was discussed.
The negative side claimed that misunderstandings which happen in exchanging e-mail would be avoided by carefully choosing language [142], and that what was good about e-mail was that it is possible to express what can't be said on the phone without worrying about the language used [142]. The affirmative side showed disagreement, raising “junk e-mail” as a counter example. She implied that annoying e-mail was a result of communication in which the senders had never considered how their language irritated the receivers [143]. The negative side pointed out that the same thing happened by using telephone and if the price was cheaper they would definitely choose e-mail [144]. Again the affirmative side argued that we are more aware of the language when we talk on the phone, and that people are more irresponsible when they use e-mail [145]. These messages were classified as Phase II/A. After exchanging those arguments, Phase III: “Negotiation of meaning/co-construction of knowledge” Operation D: “Proposal and negotiation of new statements embodying compromise, co-construction” appeared in [147]. The affirmative side shifted attention from the issue of miscommunication to the nature of interpersonal communication, stating that if one cannot build a closer relationship without e-mail, then it is not a true friendship. To have good communication, one needs to be thoughtful of others with whom they are communicating. The student developed her idea further to argue that if someone gets used to communicating without thoughtfulness, they will not be able to communicate well. Although this argument was off the debate theme of “Telephone is better than mail”, participants started discussing what good communication was and they deepened their ideas as a result of the social interaction between the participants. This clearly showed that a series of arguments can be transformed from a specific and simple one of “which is better, A or B?” type question to a higher order problem such as “How should communication be carried out?”

Discussion

Here I would like to reconsider the value of debate for pedagogical use. Debates, by their nature, allow participants to have different points of view, which facilitate active interactions between the debaters. This study was able to confirm that not only conflicts of opinions occurred, but also compromise (i.e., co-construction of knowledge) during on-line dEbate sessions. While persuading others who had different viewpoints, the participants learned how to better organize their ideas by externalizing and reflecting on their thoughts by the use of the BBS.
The existence of other people served to deepen their understandings and they were able to become much more competent debaters. From such points of view, I can say that debate is a very effective activity for pedagogical purposes.
What the traditional debate format hindered was the desire of the participants to reach a compromise or a synthesis of the propositions (Gunawardena, et al., 1997), but this research shows that in some sessions the participants were able to reach a compromise and synthesis of the different positions. Although there were few, some messages were evaluated as Phase IIIs, in which participants constructed knowledge collaboratively.
As the analysis of the session on “Which is better, telephone or e-mail?” shows, the participants discussed the strengths of each medium, and their arguments developed into the issue of the fundamental nature of communication. One participant claimed, “E-mail and telephone have their own roles”. This argument might be evaluated as indecisive and weak in traditional debate. However, when we observed it from the social constructivism viewpoint, the argument could be considered to have deepened the argument. That is, the participants might have felt uncomfortable about the way they debated the topic and have been aware that they should have been more specific, so that more constructive arguments could be generated.
The analysis of online debates in this study yielded significant implications on the use of debate for pedagogical purposes. In the traditional face-to-face debates, highly evaluated aspects of the participant's behaviors have been, for example, “logic”, “analysis”, “argument”, “evidence”, “delivery”, and “questions and answers”. As far as evaluation is concerned, educational debates in the English classroom are still being carried out using these criteria mentioned above. According to Matsumoto (2001), however, this judging system disappeared in the early 1970s in the field of formal debating in Japan. Here I would like to propose how debate, including on-line debate, should be evaluated in the classroom. In this study I evaluated the interaction using three criteria, which were: quantity, persuasiveness and organization. The participants were informed of those criteria beforehand. We believe that it is necessary to decide the winners or losers to enhance the participants' motivation as is done in the traditional debate.
Matsumoto (2001), discussing evaluation methods of the debate, claimed that rather than by using the criteria such as "delivery", and "questions and answers", the debates should be judged by comparing and examining the arguments each party posted, and the team which presents the most collaborative and constructive ideas in the very last session wins. That is, to make the interaction more collaborative, we should rate the performance based on the presentation of new and better ideas, new constructed knowledge, or showing the solution of the problem. All of these contribute to co-construction of meaning. This decision making process makes the debate not just a fun game, but a true problem solving task and encourages participants to become more competent debaters.

Conclusion

The most important aspect of this study has been a qualitative analysis of the CMC interaction. The analyses were made how the Japanese NNSs of English at college level interacted with each other and how they collaboratively constructed knowledge.
The analyses indicated that the co-construction of knowledge through social interaction occurred during the sessions, and that on-line debate was an excellent medium for generating “Phase II” arguments; expressing cognitive dissonance or inconsistency among ideas. Although the debate format did seem to hinder the participants from arriving at compromise or a synthesis of ideas, some “Phase III” arguments expressing co-construction of knowledge appeared. Therefore, it would be interesting to utilize Gunawardena et al.'s model to analyze different types of CMC formats such as e-mail exchanges and computer assisted classroom discussions to determine if they support or hinder the co-construction of knowledge through social negotiation.
This research was conducted with only small groups of participants (N=6), and all of them knew each other. As a result, further research is needed to examine the effects of other interactional variables, including how participants exchange their opinions in a larger scale situation, such as overseas teleconferences. Finally, further research into NS-NNS interactions in a similar forum would be valuable.

Author

Teruo Fujiike is a Japanese teacher of English at Akashi Senior High School in Hyogo Prefecture, Japan. He received his Master's degree in school education from Hyogo University of Teacher Education. His research interests are in Internet-based language learning in the classroom and on-line discourse analysis.

Notes

Note 1: This study derives from my Master of school education thesis presented to Hyogo University of Teacher Education in 2002. (Fujiike, 2002)
Note 2: In order to maintain the confidentiality of participants, they are identified by one alphabetical letter from A to F.
Note 3: The first coder's decisions are read horizontally and the second coder's decisions are read vertically. Numbers on the diagonal indicate agreement between the coders. Numbers off the diagonal indicate disagreement. The disagreements between two raters were worked out through discussion until agreement was met.
Note 4: The head of each message indicates the followings: “[041]”: The first digit “0” refer to Dyad A, “1” to Dyad B and “2” to Dyad C. The other two digits means a serial number of the messages posted between the pairs. “Con:B” represents that a contributor B is on the negative side. “Pro: A” represents that a contributor A is on the affirmative side. “2002/06/20 16:50”: Date and Time.

References

  • Beauvois, M.H. (1992). Computer-Assisted Classroom Discussion in the Foreign Language Classroom: Conversation in Slow Motion. Foreign Language Annals, 25, 455-464.
  • Chun, D. (1994). Using computer networking to facilitate the acquisition of interactive competence. System, 22, 17-31.
  • Cohen, Jacob. (1960). Coefficient of Agreement For Nominal Scales. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 10(1), 37-46.
  • Cononelos, T., & Oliva, M. (1993). Using computer networks to enhance foreign language/culture education. Foreign Language Annals, 26, 527-534.
  • Garrison, D.R. (1991). Critical thinking and adult education: a conceptual model for developing critical thinking in adult learners. International Journal of Lifelong Education, 10, 287-303.
  • Garrison, D.R., T. Anderson, W. Archer. (2001). Critical Thinking, Cognitive Presence, and Computer Conferencing in Distance Education. The American Journal of Distance Education, 15, 7-23.
  • Gunawardena, Charlotte N., Lowe, Constance A., Anderson, Terry. (1997). Analysis of a Global Online Debate and the Development of an Interaction Analysis Model for Examining Social construction of knowledge in Computer Conferencing. Educational Computing Research 17, 397-431.
  • Henri, F. (1991). Computer Conferencing and Content Analysis In Kaye, A. (Ed.) Collaborative Learning through Computer Conferencing: The Najaden papers. London: Springer-Verlag, 117-136.
  • Holsti, O. (1969). Content analysis for the social sciences and humanities. Don Mills, ON: Addison-Wesley.
  • Kelm, O. (1992). The use of synchronous computer networks in second language instruction: A preliminary report. Foreign Language Annals, 25, 441-454.
  • Kern, R. (1995). Restructuring Classroom Interaction with Networked Computers: Effects on Quantity and Characteristics of Language Production. The Modern Language Journal, 79, 457-476.
  • Kitade, K. (2000). L2 Learners' Discourse and SLA Theories in CMC: Collaborative Interaction in Internet Chat. Computer Assisted Language Learning. 13(2), 143-166.
  • Lee, L. (2002). Enhancing Learners' Communication Skills through Synchronous Electronic Interaction and Task-Based Instruction. Foreign Language Annals, 35, 16-23.
  • Lightbown, P., & Pienemann, M. (1993). Comments on Stephen D. Krashen's teaching issues: Formal grammar instruction. TESOL Quarterly, 27, 717-722.
  • Matsumoto, S. (2001). Dibeito Kyouiku no Mokuteki to Hohoron o Saiko Suru?: Online. Internet. 5 Oct. 2002. Available URL: http://coe-sun.kuis.ac.jp/coe/public/paper/outside/matsumoto3.pdf
  • Newman, D.R., B. Webb, and C. Cochrane. (1995). A Content Analysis Method to Measure Critical Thinking in Face-to-face and Computer Supported Group Learning, Interpersonal Computing and Technology: An Electronic Journal for the 21st Century, 3(2), 56-77.
  • Newman, D., Griffin, P., and Cole, M. (1989) The construction zone: Working for cognitive change in school. Cambridge: Cambridge UP.
  • Pellettieri, J. (2000). Negotiation in cyberspace: The role of chatting in the development of grammatical competence. Network-based Language Teaching: Concepts and Practice. Eds. Warschauer, M., and R. Kern. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 59-86
  • Toyoda E. (2002). Categorization of Text Chat Communication Between Learners and Native Speakers of Japanese." Language Learning & Technology, 6, 82-99.
  • Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in Society. Harvard University Press.
  • Warschauer, M. (1996). Comparing Face-To-Face and Electronic Discussion in the Second Language Classroom. CALICO Journal, 13, 7-25.

Appendix 1: Interaction Analysis Model (Gunawardena, et al., 1997)

PHASE I: SHARING/COMPARING OF INFORMATION. Stage one operations include:
  1. A statement of observation or opinion [PhI/A]
  2. A statement of agreement from one or more other participants [PhI/B]
  3. Corroborating examples provided by one or more participants [PhI/C]
  4. Asking and answering questions to clarify details of statements [PhI/D]
  5. Definition, description, or identification of a problem [PhI/E]

PHASE II: THE DISCOVERY AND EXPLORATION OF DISSONANCE OR INCONSISTENCY AMONG IDEAS, CONCEPTS OR STATEMENTS. (This is the operation at the group level of what Festinger calls cognitive dissonance, defined as an inconsistency between a new observation and the learner's existing framework of knowledge and thinking skills.) Operations which occur at this stage include.
  1. Identifying and stating areas of disagreement [PhII/A]
  2. Asking and answering questions to clarify the source and extent of disagreement [PhII/B]
  3. Restating the participant's position, and possibly advancing arguments or considerations in its support by references to the participant's experience, literature, formal data collected, or proposal ofrelevant metaphor or analogy to illustrate point of view. [PhII/C]

PHASE III: NEGOTATION OF MEANING/CO-CONSTRUCTION OF KNOWLEDGE
  1. Negotiation or clarification of the meaning of terms [PhIII/A]
  2. Negotiation of the relative weight to be assigned to types of argument [PhIII/B]
  3. Identification of areas of agreement or overlap among conflicting concepts [PhIII/C]
  4. Proposal and negotiation of new statements embodying compromise, co-construction [PhIII/D]
  5. Proposal of integrating or accommodating metaphors or analogies [PhIII/E]

PHASE IV: TESTING AND MODIFICATION OF PROPOSED SYNTHESIS OR CO-CONSTRUCTION
  1. Testing the proposed synthesis against "received fact" as shared by the participants and/or their culture [PhIV/A]
  2. Testing against existing cognitive schema [PhIV/B]
  3. Testing against personal experience [PhIV/C]
  4. Testing against formal data collected [PhIV/D]
  5. Testing against contradictory testimony in the literature [PhIV/E]

PHASE V: AGREEMENT STATEMENT(S)/APPLICATIONS OF NEWLY-CONSTRUCTED MEANING
  1. Summarization of agreements(s) [PhV/A]
  2. Applications of new knowledge [PhV/B]
  3. Metacognitive statements by the participants illustrating their understanding that their knowledge or ways of thinking(cognitive schema) have changed as a result of the conference interaction [PhV/C]

Interaction analysis model for examining social construction of knowledge in computer conferencing.

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4


source: http://callej.org/

Cognitive Skills in Translating: Creating a web-based learning activity

Cognitive Skills in Translating: Creating a web-based learning activity

  • ISSN 1442-438X
  • CALL-EJ Online
  • Vol. 5, No. 1, June 2003


Paper Presented at Horwood Language Centre, University of Melbourne, 3 December 2002
Intended Audience: K-12 teachers interested in using computers, language teachers

Pedagogical Background

Regardless of the approach on which their instruction has been based, once learners reach a certain level of proficiency in a foreign language, they become increasingly aware of the value of translation as a skill, a tool and an art. They also understand that it is one of many ways for themselves and others to gauge their ability to move across linguistic and cultural frontiers, and appreciate that it is a powerful catalyst for reflection on the nature of language systems. So, in spite of the virtually total eclipse of grammar-translation as the foundation of foreign language learning, translation has justifiably remained an integral part of many intermediate and advanced level courses. It is also the substance of courses aimed specifically at training bilingual speakers to become professional translators and interpreters. The conduct of a translation class, however, provides both teacher and learner with numerous challenges.
Students need to be given adequate opportunity to produce translations which will be evaluated by experts. Practice is an inescapable part of the process of becoming a proficient translator. Frequent encounters with points at which the two language systems diverge allow students to recognise them quickly and to develop reflex strategies for dealing with them. They also hone the complex and at times laborious skills associated with bilingual and monolingual dictionary use.
Learners also need feedback. Typically, at university, a translation assignment is handed out to students one week, submitted the next, and returned in the third week. The delay between the time at which students are actually engaging in the act of translation and when they receive feedback on the success or otherwise of their efforts is problematic. A week or two after the event, students are not always inclined or able to spend time re-analysing the different pathways through a linguistic maze, delving into the complex interrelation of words and ideas within and across sentences, or focusing again on the subtle nuances that distinguish between the many solutions that present themselves for a given problem. If the translation passage is part of an assessment program, the single most important piece of feedback is usually the mark. Students have done the work, the mark is the reward, and all the reflection in the world is not going to alter that. They basically just want to get on with the next assessable task.
From the point of view of the teacher there are other dilemmas. Firstly, no two student translations are the same. Each represents a unique combination of skills, strategies and inadequacies. Each script therefore requires a different set of feedback, and it would be possible to spend a great deal of time in fruitful discussion with every student, one-to-one. This is a task which very few teachers have either the opportunity or inclination to perform, and a luxury which very few institutions could afford. To convert the content of such discussion to written explanations would require considerably more time again. The problem increases in pBoportion to the number of translations students are given to help them master the art, and is exacerbated by the fact that even if written comments were tailored to each student's work, a great many of them would remain unread or undigested. And a lesson in which the teacher attempts to address the needs of every student, may actually meet those of none.
There is also a need for objectivity in weighing up alternatives in translation. To discuss a passage which students have not made a serious attempt to translate can be a very worthwhile task, but there is no guarantee that they will be able to apply the fruits of the collective intellectual labour in performing subsequent translation tasks. However, to discuss a passage which students have made a serious attempt to translate generates a completely different set of problems, mainly of an affective nature. If a corrected translation is handed back to students along with a fair copy, they generally have little difficulty in accepting a situation in which their version, while different, has been deemed equivalent and acceptable by ’higher authority’ in the form of the teacher. It is a different matter, however, in cases where the student translation is signalled as deficient in some respect, particularly when the problem flagged is one of idiom, style or register, rather than grammar, syntax or spelling. Any teacher who has taught a translation class will probably be familiar with the ease with which what begins as a reasoned discussion can, unchecked, flare up into a heated and irrational bun fight once students begin to defend their efforts in relation to the model of a fair copy, and especially in relation to the efforts of their fellow students. Positions tend to be defended even more strongly when the direction of the translation is into the student's mother tongue. Any hint of correction can easily be taken as a slur on first- language proficiency, and the degree of offence taken tends to be proportional to the sense of ownership, which in turn is usually a function of the effort invested in the task. It is in fact very difficult, in the time frame typically associated with translation exercises, to establish the personal and temporal distance necessary for objective analysis. The principle of affective blindness can apply equally to teacher and student.
This paper presents and analyses a web-based activity, ‘Translator Choice’, whose development represents an attempt to use information technology as a means of fostering the cognitive skills required by foreign-language students in their mastery of translation. It will look in turn at the ‘surface structure’ of the activity as encountered by the student, the teacher rationale, the data base on which an activity is constructed, and the returns for the effort and expertise invested by the teacher.

Surface Structure

There are two activities, ‘Select the Most Accurate Translation’ (or ‘Select One’) (see Fig. 1 for basic work screen), and ‘Rank the Translations’ (see Fig. 2 for basic work screen). Each activity can be done in practice or test mode. The alternative translations are displayed in random order each time the screen is presented. On completion of each activity students are awarded a score based on the degree to which their choice or ranking of translations corresponded with the teacher-preferred classification.

Fig. 1 Basic work screen for ‘Select One’ activity

The mechanics of the student's interaction with the material is summarised in the instructions for the activity.

‘Select One’ Instructions:
  • In this activity you are presented with a segment of the passage followed by a set of suggested translations.
  • The translations vary in their accuracy.
  • Click on the translation you consider to be the most accurate. To change your selection, click on a different translation.
  • Once you are satisfied with your choice, click ‘Lock In My Answer’ to register your answer.
  • Once you have locked in your answer, you may wish to use the ‘Show Feedback’ button to explore the merits of the various translations.
  • Click ‘Next Segment’ to move to the next segment of the translation.
  • The ‘View your translation so far’ link allows you to see the current segment in the context of the whole passage at any stage of the activity. It also displays the text of the translation constructed through your choices to that point.

By way of example, the following is the feedback available to a student considering the merits of the fourth-ranked translation:
According to some witnesses, the murderer, a young man, healthy, fair-haired, and built like a surfer,
for the segment:
Selon des témoins, le tueur, un jeune homme blond portant la tenue d'un surfeur,
in the passage ‘Tuerie en Tasmanie’.
Feedback:

some witnesses: ‘selon des témoins’ means ‘according to witnesses’. Although it is possible for the French indefinite article ‘des’ to mean ‘some’ in English, to use ‘some’ here is overtranslation. It may be misleading, suggesting that other witnesses’ opinions differed. If the French had intended to emphasise ‘some’ in this context (i.e. to indicate a quantity), the word ‘quelques’ or ‘certains’ would have been used: ‘selon quelques témoins’, ‘selon certains témoins’.
murderer: ‘killer’ is a more appropriate term in this context. Killings tend to be random, but murder tends to pre-suppose a specific victim.
healthy: This is added information. The original doesn't indicate whether he is healthy or not. The probable source of this error is careless dictionary use. ‘portant’ here is used as the present participle of the verb ‘porter’ (to wear) – i.e. he was wearing surfie clothes. There is, however, a dictionary entry under ‘portant’ which includes the information: étre bien/mal portant – to be healthy or in good health/in poor health.
built like a surfer: The meaning of ‘la tenue’ here is ‘clothing’, and ‘portant la tenue d’un surfeur’ means ‘wearing surfer's clothes’ or ‘dressed like a surfie’.


Fig. 2 Basic work screen for ‘Rank the Translations’ activity


Rank the Translations Instructions:
  • In the ‘Rank the Translations: Practice’ activity you are presented with a segment of the passage followed by a set of suggested translations.
  • The translations vary in their accuracy.
  • Each of the translations is accompanied by a set of buttons.
  • Click on the buttons to grade the translations (1 = most accurate; highest number = least accurate)
  • All suggested translations must be given a ranking.
  • No two translations can be assigned the same ranking.
  • You may change your preferences at any time by clicking on another button in the same row.
  • Once you are satisfied with your choices, you may click “Lock In My Answer” to register your answers and either compare them with the Recommended Ranking or move directly to the Next Segment.
  • The ‘View Full Passage’ button allows you to see the current segment in the context of the whole passage at any stage of the activity.

Teacher rationale

The ‘Translator Choice’ activity is not intended as a substitute for traditional translation exercises, but as a complement to them. It provides a new dimension by enabling learners to encounter and evaluate a range of translations of the same original text. In doing so it takes them beyond the frequently restricted and restrictive world of the apprentice translator, which is typically bounded by the keyboard (or pen and paper), reference material (grammars; dictionaries; comparable documents in the source and target language, web-based or printed), and the student's own intellectual resources. One of the criteria in selecting the variants displayed on the screen is that at some stage they have actually been produced by a genuine translator or would-be translator. And since the variants will seldom if ever have been generated by the students doing the activity, they are in a position to consider the various alternatives in a dispassionate manner, with no vested interest or personal pride to protect. In the case of practice activities they have the choice of working either individually or in small groups, where the final choice can be the result of discussion and negotiation with fellow students.
The results of a preliminary on-paper trial of the exercise in class were of particular interest. The students, who had been given the passage as a translation exercise (part of a larger assignment) the previous year, were a subset of the group from whose written translations the 5 variants had been compiled. When their assignments had been handed back the previous year, accompanied by a fair copy, their reactions had been entirely consistent with that of other generations of students. The assertive or confident or desperate among them had used the corrections indicated on the returned assignments as a platform for launching a public justification of their choices, either in the hope of forcing some concession from the teacher that would result in an upward adjustment of their grade, or as a means sending some signal to their fellow students about the injustice of objective assessment (i.e. exact percentage scores, and any judgement of ‘right and wrong’) being applied to what they were, at least for the sake of that particular debate, choosing to represent as an art. (In that atmosphere the teacher sensed that the students would not have been entirely receptive to the observation that some findings claim that machine translation systems achieve, on average, about 65% as well as expert human translators (ANDERSON, D. 1995:68)) And the less assertive, regardless of the strength of their convictions or the amount of effort they had put into the task, had accepted the rulings of the authority figure, or at least chosen not to voice any disagreement with them.
For the class activity students were divided into groups of 3 and given several consecutive segments of the passage, each accompanied by 5 alternative translations in random order. Students were asked to discuss the alternatives and rank them by accuracy. Virtually without exception their agreed rankings corresponded with those of the teacher. And the fact that none of the students identified personally with any of the variants they were evaluating meant that all justification of choices and deference or concession to the opinions of fellow students was based on linguistic rather than affective premises.
By removing the pencil, paper and reference book components, the web-based activity allows student to focus exclusively on meaning and expression. And it is infinitely less awkward to administer than its on-paper predecessor. To reach a decision requires students to weigh each variant up against the original text and each of the alternatives, and to look at both the detail of the individual semantic units, and the structure and style of the segment as a whole. Students are encouraged to consult dictionaries and other reference materials in the process. At the cognitive level it is in many respects a more demanding task than the production of a single translation, since implied in the process is the need for students to have formed their own clear idea of the meaning of the original. They must then proceed to weigh it up against the set of alternatives, some of which will be more accurate and complete expressions of that meaning than their own version, some less. And given that students are aware that they have only to recognise, rather than produce, an exemplary translation, they sense that their chances of scoring well are higher. The relationship between the activity and conventional translation is similar to that between listening comprehension and speaking, or reading comprehension and writing.
In the ‘Select One’ practice activity students have access to a comprehensive bank of feedback for each translation variant. Workload constraints have previously prevented the author from ever even considering this luxury for his students in 30 years of teaching.
In addition to providing students with a different angle from which to view translation, the computer-managed activities allow the teacher to be confident that students are devoting a certain amount of time to the task without the need for personal supervision or presence in a single classroom. This in turn allows the teacher to focus on other matters during formal class hours.

Data Input

The creation of an activity is essentially an extension of a conventional class translation exercise.
In addition to selecting a passage appropriate to the academic level and professional orientation of the students, and grading their individual performances in that assignment, the teacher has to take the following steps:
  • Divide the passage into a set of discrete sense units (segments). Segment boundaries tend to fall naturally at sentence boundaries, as sentences normally represent the expression of an independent unit of thought. In the case of complex sentences, there are usually natural cleavage points at which it is possible to split the discourse, thus preventing students from having to reflect on and compare unwieldy chunks of text on screen.
  • Using the full range of student translations generated from the class exercise, compile a set of 5 translations of each segment of varying degrees of accuracy and as fully representative as possible of the range problems and solutions associated with conveying the meaning of the original text in the target language.
  • For each alternative translation, compile feedback to explain each point at which it fails to accurately represent the meaning of the original.

A sample compilation of feedback for a single segment is provided in Appendix 1. In this sample, the segment is coded G (it is the 6th segment of the passage), the 5 alternative translations, in order of accuracy, are coded G1-5, and feedback for each translation is coded using lower-case letters (e.g. G4a-d). Once prepared in this form, the data can easily be pasted into the template, and further modified if required (e.g. as a result of input from site users).

Investments and Returns

As data entry fields have been designed to accept and display both standard keyboard input and paste-in graphics, activities can be created for languages from the full spectrum of writing systems. And because the exercises generated are of a receptive and cognitive nature, there is no requirement for students to type in any data. This facet of the design eliminated any need for programmers to create open-ended, unpredictable and costly routines for checking infinitely variable data input by students.
With regard to delivery (i.e. the electronic equivalent of preparing the worksheets handed out to students in the preliminary on-paper version), the computer does all the work, including randomising the display of choices and grading responses. As with any activity, IT-based or not, this exercise can only have the full desired influence on students' learning if it is thoroughly and formally integrated into a course structure and assessment procedures.
Generation of the material is unquestionably painstaking, and the investment of effort and expertise on the part of the teacher in constructing the range of alternative translations and in preparing the feedback would simply not be justifiable for a single class. However, once it exists in electronic form, the activity becomes part of a bank of exercises that can be used by groups of students in other institutions nationally or internationally. Any exercise can be designated as either practice or test, and can be given an ‘active’ or ‘archived’ classification. By giving a teaching resource the capacity to transcend geographical and temporal boundaries, the web platform brings into play an economy of scale factor previously precluded from the individual teacher's equation for materials preparation. One exercise, if carefully constructed, can serve many classes in many institutions over many years. The web base also changes the balance of factors in the teacher-student equation, as it allows the intellectual resources and the time and energy spent in preparation by many teachers to be made available to small groups of students or even to individual learners. The potential scope and longevity of any activity, however, creates a commensurate responsibility on the part of those who manage it to ensure a high level of quality control.

Concluding Remarks

The ‘Translator Choice’ site is not a panacea. It is, like the Transit-TIGER advanced technical translation materials developed by D. Thompson at the University of Hull, an aid in the training of students in translation that enlists the support of computers to manage processes and present information in ways not possible with traditional media in traditional classrooms. It can be used to enrich instruction, free up class time and administer assessable work in a specified time frame.
The activities it generates allow students to achieve objectivity in their appraisal of translation alternatives, and to receive as much or as little feedback on the nature and sources of inaccuracy in those alternatives as they want or require. It is a tool for assembling and preserving resources and expertise in virtually any language, and for disseminating them to a scattered public and over many years. The reservoir of resources requires some management but little in the way of maintenance or ongoing commitment of funds. But like any such resource, it is only as rich as the academic content around which it is built.

Acknowledgements

Professor Sharon Bell, Dean, Faculty of Arts, University of Wollongong, for her support and encouragement, and for her vital role in enabling the project.
Mr Ray Stace, Manager, Educational Development Services, Centre for Educational Development and Interactive Resources (CEDIR), University of Wollongong, for his advice and patience in helping me frame the project in the idiom of IT.
Mr David Elsner, Web Developer/Programmer, The Education Media Laboratory (emlab), Faculty of Education, University of Wollongong, for dedicated and eager application of his skills to converting the specifications into a fully functional site.
Mr Owen McKerrow, Web Developer/Programmer, The Education Media Laboratory (emlab), Faculty of Education, University of Wollongong, for his skill in grasping concepts and specifications expressed by an IT layman and in overseeing their conversion into a Web-based reality.
Mr Robert Wright, Project Director, The Education Media Laboratory (emlab), Faculty of Education, University of Wollongong, for picking up the project and running with it.

References

  • ANDERSON, Don D., ‘Machine Translation as a Tool in Second Langauge Learning’, CALICO Journal Vol. 13/1, p68 (1995), citing the results of the evaluation for the third quarter of WHITE, J.S. et al., ‘The ARPA (Advanced Research Projects Agency) MT Evaluation Methodologies: Evolution, Lessons, and Future Approaches’, AMTA, 1994, 193-205.
  • THOMPSON, D. & J. Thompson, ‘Advanced (Technical) Translation (Italian/English): A Pilot Project’, in Language Learning with Computers, An Educational Challenge, ed. Peter Baumgartner and Anthony Hall, WISL - Werkstatt für interkulturelles und soziales Lernen A - 9020 Klagenfurt, Austria, 1991, 160-173
  • THOMPSON, D. & J. Thompson, TransIt, Advanced [Technical] Translation (Italian to English) Teacher's Manual, Department of Italian, University of Hull, 1993 ISBN 085958 595 6
  • THOMPSON, J. ‘Embedding technology into language examinations: a case study’, in Active Learning ,4 (July 1996) 25-29

Author

Brian McCarthy is an Associate Professor of French, Modern Languages Program. He was appointed to the University of Wollongong as a foundation lecturer in French in 1975. His academic qualifications include a BA with 1st class honours in French, a Master of Arts, a Diploma of Education and a Doctor of Philosophy in Applied Linguistics. In 1994, he received the Vice-Chancellor's Award for Excellence in Teaching. He has been Head of the Modern Languages Program since 1999, the recipient of numerous research grants, and the author of half a dozen textbooks, over 40 research articles and 50 language-learning software modules.

Apendix

Appendix 1: Sample of segment data organised for entry into Web authoring template.


G Nous tapions dessus à coups de bâtons, nous la poursuivions avec des pierres.
G1 We would beat it with sticks and pelt it with stones.
G2 We'd hit it with sticks and went after it with rocks.
G2a we'd: This contracted form of ‘we would’ is too informal and conversational in the context (author narrating, not character speaking). Moreover, followed as it is in this translation by ‘and went after it’, ‘we'd’ could be considered ambiguous, as the same contraction can be used for ‘we had’.
G2b went after it: The French uses the imperfect for both verbs (‘tapions’, ‘poursuivions’), and this indicates that both actions were routinely performed by the children. In this translation two different forms are used, the first ‘we'd hit’ represents the action as a past repeated one, the second ‘we went’ suggests that the second action may have been a one-off event. Suggested translation: ‘and (we would) go after it’
G3 We would beat her with sticks and we'd chase her with stones.
G3a her: There is nothing to suggest that the animal was female. French grammar conventions require the form ‘la’ to used in ‘nous la poursuivions’ because the word ‘bête’ is grammmatically feminine. This does not necessarily imply that the word refers to a female: ‘un lion’, ‘un tigre’, and ‘un chien’ would all be described as ‘une bête’, so would ‘une chèvre’ and ‘une vache’. Suggested translation: ‘beat it with sticks’
G3b we'd chase: This contracted form of ‘we would’ is too informal and conversational in the context (author narrating, not character speaking). Repetition of the auxiliary verb ‘would’ here places unnecessary emphasis on the repeated nature of the action. Even if this emphasis were justified stylistically, it would be very unusual to use two different forms (‘we would’ and ‘we'd’). Suggested translation: ‘We would beat… and chase…’
G4 We would strike it with blows from sticks, and aim for it with stones.
G4a strike: This synonym for ‘hit’ or ‘beat’ has a slightly literary or technical connotation in the context, wherease the word ‘taper’ is relatively informal.
G4b strike it with blows: This translation introduces a tautology (= ‘needless repetition of an idea, especially in other words in the immediate context’) for which there is no basis in the original.
G4c sticks,: The comma is used after ‘bâtons’ in the original to separate the two ideas ‘nous tapions’ and ‘nous poursuivions’, thus presenting them as a list. This stylistic technique does not work well in English in this context, and this has been recognised by the use of ‘and’ to separate the ideas in the translation. However, as the word ‘and’ replaces the comma of the original, the comma in the translation after ‘sticks’ is redundant.
G4d aim for it: Mistranslation. The word ‘poursuivre’ means ‘to pursue’, ‘to chase (after)’. The normal French equivalent of ‘aim (for)’ is ‘viser’.
G5 We were beating it with sticks, we continued with rocks.
G5a were beating: The imperfect tense (‘nous tapions’) can convey two basic meanings in English: a past continuous action (=‘we were (in the process of) beating’), or a past repeated action (=‘we used to beat, we would beat’). In this context it clearly refer to a repeated action, i.e. something the children did regularly. Suggested translation: ‘we would beat’
G5b sticks,: The comma is used after ‘bâtons’ in the original to separate the two ideas ‘nous tapions’ and ‘nous poursuivions’, thus presenting them as a list. This stylistic technique does not work well in English in this context. It is standard practice to use the word ‘and’ instead of a comma.
G5c we continued: (i) Mistranslation. The word ‘poursuivre’ can mean ‘to continue’ (e.g. poursuivre ses études = to continue one's studies). The principal meaning of the word, however, is ‘to pursue, to chase, to hunt down’, and this is clearly the meaning in this context. The children are hunting an animal. (ii) The ‘la’ of ‘nous la poursuivions’ has been omitted from the translation. (iii) The French uses the imperfect for both verbs (‘tapions’, ‘poursuivions’), and this indicates that both actions were routinely performed by the children. The form ‘we continued’ suggests that the second action may have been a one-off event. Suggested translation: ‘and we would go after it’

source: http://callej.org/